Breaking News Bar

Guest view: Don't give vocational education the short end of the stick

  • Todd Maisch

    Todd Maisch

By Todd Maisch
President & CEO, Illinois Chamber of Commerce.
Posted on 5/9/2018, 1:00 AM

With the nation's unemployment rate continuing to drop, labor markets are in an ever-tightening vice, and Illinois employers are feeling the pain as they try to fill middle-skill jobs. There is a misguided belief that the skills gap exclusively hits at the top end of the labor market, in fields such as professional services, engineering or computer sciences.

While there are critical shortages across many industries, the reality is that Illinois employers struggle most to find qualified employees in fields that require more than a high school diploma, but also certifications and skills not provided by a two- or four-year college program. As a result, resources are being diverted away from vocational programs in our high schools, and soon-to-be graduates are being directed away from high-quality technical education programs, simply because they aren't part of the traditional college track.

The reality is there are great careers available in the skilled trades, but not enough people with the right training and skills to fill them.

In the past several months, I visited with hiring managers at dozens of transportation companies. The career outlook for automotive and diesel technicians is incredibly strong due to Illinois' position as a national transportation and logistics hub.

But every employer I spoke with told me they can't find enough qualified entry-level technicians to hire.

If we want to help Illinois employers grow, and serve all our students, we have to stop categorizing skilled trades based on old ways of thinking. Beyond that, we have to embrace that while college may be right for many, it is not the only path to success and economic security.

The fact is, many industry-supported certificate and credentialing programs can be completed faster, at significantly lower cost, with as good, if not better long-term career outlooks than traditional liberal arts programs. Data in the U.S. Department of Education's College Scorecard shows that students who choose a quality postsecondary technical education may actually earn more, on average, 10 years after starting their program than peers at four-year liberal arts universities and two-year community colleges.

There is substantial value in a quality technical education, and there are countless high-quality, industry-supported training programs across Illinois that deliver skills that could take years or even a decade to earn on-the-job. These programs and providers need to be welcomed into our high schools by counselors, principals and parents, so that Illinois students are exposed to multiple paths that can lead to their future success.

Illinois' economy will be better served if we support all students and adult learners in finding programs that provide relevant skills and lead to good jobs and careers.